Scientology, the placebo of personal betterment

placebo noun

  1. a substance having no pharmacological effect but given merely to satisfy a patient who supposes it to be medicine.
  2. a substance having no pharmacological effect but administered as a control in testing experimentally or clinically the efficacy of a biologically active preparation.

placebo effect noun

  1. a reaction to a placebo manifested by a lessening of symptoms or the production of anticipated side effects.

While it may be difficult to show that any one individual Scientologist has not “gotten gains” from his or her participation in Scientology, it is trivial to determine that Scientology does not and never has produced the benefits promised by L. Ron Hubbard.

Scientology promises to produce homo novis: A significantly superior being, far superior to current homo sapiens.  This isn’t just implied, this is explicitly promised many, many times by Hubbard.

If Scientologists were routinely becoming such superior beings, it would be obvious in the real world.  The leaders of science, academia, industry, politics and more would proudly declare that they were Scientologists, products of Hubbard’s amazing “tech”.

The truth is that there are no Scientologists of any note except those few who were already famous or successful prior to Scientology.

Given that it is true and self-evident that Scientology’s “tech” does not produce the wonderful results promised, why do some believers insist that they “got gains” from Scientology?

Enter the “placebo effect”.  And here is where Hubbard really pulled off a good one.  The capabilities and attributes of this mythical homo novis are largely undefined.  In general, the attributes are virtually godlike. Anything could potentially be a homo novis ability.

And here is why it is so very effective in convincing a believer that Hubbard’s homo novis is not just possible but is actually happening:

Anything unusual that happens to a Scientologist can and is considered “proof” of progress towards this homo novis.

– Found some money you forgot you had?  It’s Scientology!
– Your favorite team wins? It’s Scientology!
– Feel especially good for a day or two? It’s Scientology!
– Had a bit of luck doing some task? It’s Scientology!
– Unexplained tingling in your hands? It’s Scientology!
… and so on.

You, of course, understand that all these things are perfectly normal things that happen to almost everyone at one time or another but, to a true believer in Scientology, anything out of the ordinary is proof that Scientology is working.

It is the placebo effect in personal betterment.  Because Scientologists still believe Hubbard’s wild promises, they will grasp at any straw that appears to validate their beliefs.  After all that money, all that fuss and bother, there must be some benefit.

Yes, it is sad. No, you can’t reason with them.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Scientology, the placebo of personal betterment

  1. Just Bruce says:

    Hi Just Bill!
    Glad to see another post from you. I’ve always enjoyed your voice.
    Long ago, when I was a not-so-true believer and at the beginning of my questioning and subsequent exit from the church and then the subject, I saw this video. I was struck how much the character Ed Begley Jr plays reminded me of scientology OTs, those supermen out there making the world a better place. And the world’s response to their efforts.

    Enjoy! It’s less than 4 minutes:

  2. Pingback: Can Scientology solve YOUR problem? | Ask the Scientologist

Leave a Reply. It will be moderated.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s